How to Tell if Eggs Are Bad: The Float Test and Other Checks

Crack the egg into a bowl and smell it: a bad egg has an unmistakable sulphur smell. The float test shows age, not safety: fresh eggs sink, old eggs stand up, and eggs that float are very old. Refrigerated eggs usually keep 3 to 5 weeks.

By Trends Editorial

Published 4 min read

In brief

How long eggs keep in and out of the fridge, what the dates on the box mean, how the float test works and what it really tells you, the sniff test, and how to store eggs safely in different countries.

The quick answer

  1. Smell it. Crack the egg into a separate bowl. A spoiled egg has a strong sulphur (rotten egg) smell, raw or cooked. If it smells bad, throw it out.
  2. Look at it. Discard eggs with cracked, slimy or powdery shells, or with pink, green, black or iridescent spots inside.
  3. Float test for age. Fresh eggs sink. Older eggs stand up. Eggs that float are very old and best thrown away.

How the float test works

Place the egg gently in a bowl of cold water.

What it doesWhat it means
Sinks and lies flat on its sideVery fresh
Sinks but tilts or stands on its endOlder, still fine to eat if it smells normal. Good for hard-boiling, because older eggs peel more easily
FloatsVery old. Most advice is to throw it away

Why it works: an egg shell is porous. Over time, moisture and carbon dioxide escape and air takes their place, so the air cell at the wide end grows and the egg becomes more buoyant.

What it does not tell you: whether the egg carries bacteria such as salmonella. A fresh-looking egg can still be contaminated, and that is why thorough cooking matters. The float test is a test of age, not safety.

The sniff test is the real test

Bacteria that spoil eggs produce hydrogen sulphide, the smell of rotten eggs. It is unmistakable. Crack eggs one at a time into a small bowl before adding them to a mixture, so one bad egg does not ruin a whole batch.

Other signs of a fresh egg once cracked:

  • A firm, rounded yolk and thick white that holds its shape.
  • Older eggs have a flatter yolk and a runny white that spreads. They are still fine to eat if they smell normal.

Things that look odd but are harmless

  • Blood spots on the yolk: a tiny blood vessel burst during laying. Safe; remove with a spoon if you prefer.
  • Cloudy white: a sign of a very fresh egg, caused by carbon dioxide that has not yet escaped.
  • Green ring around a boiled yolk: a harmless reaction from overcooking. See how to boil eggs to avoid it.
  • Stringy white bits (chalazae): the cords that hold the yolk in place. Normal.

How long eggs last

EggsStorageKeeps for
Raw, in the shellFridgeAbout 3 to 5 weeks from purchase
Raw, in the shell (unwashed, UK and EU style)Cool room, below about 20°CUp to the best-before date
Raw yolks or whitesFridge, covered2 to 4 days
Hard-boiledFridgeAbout 1 week
Raw, beatenFreezerUp to 1 year for best quality
Cooked egg dishesFridge3 to 4 days

Never freeze eggs in their shells: they crack. Our fridge storage guide has times for other foods.

What the dates on the box mean

  • United States: cartons may show a sell-by or expiration date set by the producer or state, and a pack date shown as a three-digit day-of-year code (001 is 1 January, 365 is 31 December). Properly refrigerated eggs are usually fine for 3 to 5 weeks after purchase.
  • UK and EU: eggs carry a best-before date, set at no more than 28 days after laying. It is a quality date. The UK Food Standards Agency says eggs can be eaten after it if they are cooked thoroughly until both yolk and white are solid.
  • Elsewhere: follow the date and storage instructions on the pack.

Storing eggs well

  • Keep them in their box, on a shelf rather than in the fridge door, where the temperature swings every time it opens.
  • Store pointed end down, which keeps the yolk centred and the air cell at the top.
  • Do not wash unwashed eggs before storing; it removes the natural protective coating. If an egg is dirty, wipe it just before use.
  • Once refrigerated, keep them cold. A cold egg left out sweats, and moisture on the shell helps bacteria pass through.

Cooking eggs safely

The safest eggs are cooked until the yolk and white are firm, or to 71°C (160°F) in dishes. This matters most for pregnant people, babies and young children, older adults and people with weakened immune systems. In the UK, eggs with the British Lion mark are considered safe to eat runny or raw, even for these groups. Elsewhere, use pasteurised eggs for raw-egg recipes such as homemade mayonnaise or tiramisu. Our guide to safe cooking temperatures covers other foods.

Key takeaways

  • The sniff test is the real test: a bad egg smells of sulphur.
  • The float test shows age: sinkers are fresh, floaters are very old.
  • Refrigerated eggs usually keep 3 to 5 weeks; hard-boiled eggs about a week.
  • Best-before is a quality date, not a safety date, but cook older eggs thoroughly.

Questions readers ask

Is an egg that floats bad?

Not necessarily, but it is old. An egg floats because its air cell has grown as moisture escaped through the shell over weeks. A floating egg is past its best and more likely to be spoiled, so most food safety advice is to throw it away. Crack doubtful eggs into a separate bowl and smell them.

Can you eat eggs after the best-before date?

Often, yes. A best-before date marks quality, not safety, and eggs that have been kept refrigerated are usually fine for some time after it, if they look and smell normal. Cook them thoroughly. Follow the rules in your country, since some set a use-by date instead.

How long do hard-boiled eggs last?

Hard-boiled eggs keep for about one week in the fridge, peeled or unpeeled. Refrigerate them within two hours of cooking. Peeled eggs are best kept in a covered container.

Why are eggs refrigerated in the US but not in Europe?

US eggs are washed to remove dirt and bacteria, which also removes their natural protective coating, so they must be kept cold. In the UK and much of Europe, eggs are not washed, and hens are often vaccinated against salmonella, so eggs can be stored at a cool room temperature, although the fridge still keeps them fresh longer.

Filed under

Found this useful? Pass it on.

Written by

Trends Editorial

A small editorial desk focused on practical, well-structured information that helps readers make confident decisions.

How we research and revise our stories

More from Food and nearby subjects